Tiny Core Linux

Tiny Core Extensions => TCE Talk => Topic started by: robc on May 28, 2011, 02:55:16 PM

Title: updates that may break extensions
Post by: robc on May 28, 2011, 02:55:16 PM: I have updated libxcb-util and libstartup-notification. There is a chance that these updates will break others that depend on them. These updates have already been submitted to the repo with a note that they may break others. If any of your extensions depend on these, then please test their functionality to determine if a rebuild if required.

Jason W/gutmensch, perhaps it would be worth it to give access to these extensions before overwriting the current version? That way there is time to verify which others require a rebuild.
Title: Re: updates that may break extensions
Post by: Jason W on May 28, 2011, 07:32:33 PM: I personally agree that preventing any breakage in the repo by testing first is better than finding and fixing after the fact.

I just ran a check on based on the ldd output of existing extensions for those which may be affected by this update, as there is a different file set than before in libxcb-util.tcz. There is possible more breakage, but these will not be satisfied based on library dependency, and thus are most likely broken:

Code: [Select]
Thunar.tcz blueman-2.6.tcz blueman-2.7.tcz cheese.tcz compiz-gtk-window-decorator.tcz compiz-plugins-extra.tcz compiz-plugins-main.tcz compiz.tcz compizconfig-backend-gconf.tcz compizconfig-python.tcz emerald.tcz eog.tcz evolution.tcz gnome-control-center.tcz gnome-panel.tcz gnome-power-manager.tcz gnome-python-extras.tcz gnome-settings-daemon.tcz gnome-system-monitor.tcz i3.tcz libgnome-desktop.tcz libpulseaudio.tcz libstartup-notification.tcz libwnck.tcz libxcb-util.tcz libxfce4ui.tcz libxfcegui4.tcz mousepad.tcz nautilus-open-terminal.tcz nautilus.tcz netsurf.tcz notification-daemon.tcz openbox.tcz parole.tcz pulseaudio.tcz thunar-vfs.tcz vlc.tcz xfce4-cpufreq-plugin.tcz xfce4-panel.tcz xfce4-screenshooter.tcz xfce4-weather-plugin.tcz xfdesktop.tcz xfwm4.tcz xine-lib.tcz yelp.tcz
Title: Re: updates that may break extensions
Post by: Jason W on May 28, 2011, 07:45:03 PM: My vote is for a reinstating of the previous libxcb-util.tcz until a coordinated update can be done to prevent a broken repo.

I don't see a file list change for libstartup-notification, so if at least from that angle there is no easy way to check for breakage.
Title: Re: updates that may break extensions
Post by: Jason W on May 28, 2011, 07:51:11 PM: Ok, I read the new libstartup-notification depends on the xcb-util update, so perhaps it should be reverted too.

In fact, I will go ahead and do this to prevent a broken repo, and a solution then can be duscussed.
Title: Re: updates that may break extensions
Post by: Jason W on May 29, 2011, 08:31:12 PM: We will think of a way to provide testing access for extension updates that break things in the current repo, that will allow folks whose extensions will be affected to rebuild them with the new package.

Since it is relatively late in the 3.x life cycle, I would recommend that the libxcb-util/libstartupnotification updates wait until the 4.x repo. But I am ok if the affected extension makers would like to see a coordinated rebuild the above packages with the updated libxcb-util/libstartupnotification, just let me know and we will go from there.
Title: Re: updates that may break extensions
Post by: bmarkus on May 30, 2011, 02:09:18 AM: I do not have time to test and rebuild packages just because of a broken library in the chain. Do not cure the result, fix the root cause. Aka keep versions compatible with the repo even if they are not the latest and working. Just look at RedHat repo :)